K-Pop Fans Debate Why Girl Group KiiiKiii Hasn't Reached Stardom

泡菜鄉民 6 min read

They perfectly embodied a Y2K concept.
Many believed a new Y2K girl group, following in NewJeans' footsteps, had arrived.
But for some reason, they've encountered unexpected difficulties.

Instagram

Here is a translation of comments from Korean netizens:

1. Isn't it simply because fourth-generation girl groups are so dominant right now? It's not just KiiiKiii; the entire idol scene doesn't feel like it has fully transitioned into the fifth generation, and fourth-gen groups still wield significant influence. It's not that KiiiKiii isn't popular, but that fourth-gen groups are too strong, so it might take more time to assess their impact.
2. Limitations of a small to mid-sized agency. With IVE (아이브) at the top, they can't capture the public's attention. In terms of members, KiiiKiii actually has a better lineup than Hearts2Hearts, but agency power remains crucial.
3. Isn't achieving this much less than a year after debut quite good?

4. The next generation of girl groups emerged too quickly. Fourth-gen groups are currently in their prime, making it difficult for KiiiKiii to establish themselves.
5. It's unclear who the group's center is. The most distinctive and eye-catching member in a group typically becomes the center. Ha-eum (하음) has a more prominent aura, while Leesol (리솔) doesn't seem well-suited to be the center.
6. KiiiKiii lacks individual buzz. If the agency did more promotion, they could likely become popular, but Starship Entertainment (스타쉽엔터테인먼트) doesn't seem very adept at promotion.

7. IVE is an anomaly; KiiiKiii is probably Starship's normal level.
8. KiiiKiii through the eyes of old K-pop fans.
9. Isn't this already considered popular? No one expects them to achieve top-tier success, haha. There's a reason everyone wants to join a major agency, and IVE's success proves it.

10. Both "I DO ME" and "DANCING ALONE" are good songs, but there isn't a particularly striking member. IVE's Rei (레이), blonde Liz (리즈), and other members are all outstanding, but KiiiKiii seems to have gained popularity primarily through their songs, similar to NMIXX (엔믹스) in their early debut days.
11. The concept for "I DO ME" was really good, with a somewhat hippie and fresh vibe. It would be great if their subsequent songs could continue that atmosphere.
12. The concept direction was a bit overdone. This kind of concept should slowly build empathy and excitement, but they performed it too intensely, like they were shouting, "We are youth!"

13. Personally, KiiiKiii, Hearts2Hearts, NMIXX, and BABYMONSTER (베이비몬스터) don't have members with the same star power as their predecessors, yet fans are hyping them up as the next generation of powerful groups, which makes me feel like K-pop is nearing its end.
14. The songs after "I DO ME" are crucial. They should have capitalized on the momentum after "I DO ME," but unfortunately, they didn't.
15. The problem is that the songs don't capture people's hearts. It would, of course, be better if they could maintain the quality of "I DO ME."

16. "I DO ME" is good, but they need to work harder.
17. Among groups that don't follow the "Girl Crush" concept, KiiiKiii and Hearts2Hearts are still somewhat known, and I hope they become more popular. I'm a bit tired of seeing too many "Girl Crush" and Chinese-concept groups.
18. I hope the practice of deliberately lowering voices disappears; it sounds awkward, and I don't like that direction. Some husky voices are pleasant, but KiiiKiii's Kya (캬) and Leesol (리솔) don't sound good.

19. Isn't this already considered popular? No one expects them to achieve top-tier success, haha. There's a reason everyone wants to join a major agency, and IVE's success proves it.
20. The new year just started, and yet this year is already ending; it gives me goosebumps.
21. NewJeans' (뉴진스) promotion was too strong, and KiiiKiii's debut was controversial due to issues with IVE's treatment, turning two large fanbases into enemies... This isn't KiiiKiii's fault, and their songs are good, but the excessive promotion was off-putting. Some even said they didn't want to listen to KiiiKiii's songs when they came out... The idols themselves are not at fault, but their image is still very important ㅠㅠ

22. NewJeans' debut and subsequent activities are legendary. I think KiiiKiii is good too, though?
23. Working with elementary schoolers is really hard.
24. If IVE didn't have Jang Won-young (장원영) and An Yu-jin (안유진), they might not be so popular.

25. I followed KiiiKiii when they first debuted and really liked their concept and members. But it felt like they ran out of prepared material after their debut ㅠㅠ They should have created more self-produced content or other things at that time.
26. I think they should promote other members instead of Ji-woo (지우). For example, having Leesol appear on more music shows; they should do something.
27. If a girl group's voices are too low, the public generally doesn't like it, even if it might be charming for individuals.

28. Ji-woo is hardworking and kind, but on stage, she always seems to be feigning excitement. Perhaps because she naturally looks cute with her round, wide-open eyes, it appears she's pretending to be happy. Being a bit more natural would be better. Kya should smile more on stage.
29. The concept for their debut song was well-set, but it feels like it's been going downhill since then. However, I personally really like KiiiKiii's songs; they have a very K-pop feel, and the overall atmosphere is good.
30. The sudden drop in concept quality after "I DO ME" is the reason.

31. The songs and vocal style aren't great; they have a strange YG (와이지) feel. When I hear the singing on the street, I want to cover my ears. The members are pretty, but it's a shame.
32. I originally thought they would disappear quickly, but at least they're still holding on, so isn't that pretty good?
33. There isn't a member with a face that attracts fans. The overall style is too similar, and on top of that, there's IVE, the strongest fourth-gen girl group. Until a group like NewJeans, where every member is beautiful and has personality, appears, it's hard to compete with fourth-gen girl groups. Despite that, I still like their songs and hope KiiiKiii becomes popular.

34. I've also seen comments on Hearts2Hearts' posts where everyone thought there would be a successor after NewJeans, but there isn't an idol in the fifth generation who can fill NewJeans' void. In the past, every top idol debuted with a sudden explosion; no one became popular after being unknown. But do any fifth-gen rookies have that kind of impact?
35. IVE is too strong; everyone's attention is on IVE, so KiiiKiii naturally gets overshadowed.
36. KiiiKiii's members might also see these comments, so let's not be overly critical~

泡菜鄉民

泡菜鄉民

欸欸~我跟你說韓國娛樂啊...

Cheer the stars of this story

Log in to start collecting cheers on this article:

  • Read +5
  • Early reader +5 · 20 spots left
  • Comment +10
  • First comment +20
Log in for the early-reader bonus — 20 spots left

comments (0)

Related Posts

韓娛熱議-GD演唱會最終場心得熱議討論

韓娛熱議-GD演唱會最終場心得

老實說,繼MAMA之後沒有抱太大期待去看,但真的超好看哈哈哈哈哈有點誇張地說,這是我至今看過的演唱會中最厲害的之一..現場演唱毫無瑕疵,舞台表現力真的超狂,他根本就是天生的藝人..演唱會持續了4個小時,但完全沒感覺時間在流逝 下面是韓網的評論翻譯 1.真的超讚!明年BIGBANG的演唱會我一定要去,但是搶票肯定超激烈的,嗚嗚。2.撒嬌超多,粉絲管理也超厲害,漂亮又帥又可愛,真的讓我被圈粉了!3.真的最終場才是最讚的,超好看! 4.在GD的公開活動和演唱會時,我驚訝地發現有很多男粉絲,年輕的、年長的都有,還有很多夫妻一起來,真的讓我驚訝。5.參加了第一次演唱會。在GD登場的瞬間我驚呆了,他真的很有魅力。回憶滿滿,玩得很開心。我嗓子都喊啞了哈哈。6.4小時的演唱會還想多表演一點,還準備了很多活動和粉絲禮物,真的是瘋了。 7.這次演唱會還送了3萬元的Ador巧克力,這樣下去我只能當一輩子GD的粉絲了。8.我在短影片上看到他唱《只會流淚的傻瓜》,真的是唱得超好,彷彿回到了過去的GD,聽了之後馬上去找這首歌來聽,真的是名曲啊。9.果然最終場才是王道,去那裡的人真讓人羨慕。 10.粉絲們只要我最愛的歌手對我笑著打招呼就很開心了...看到MAMA的表演後,真的很擔心他的嗓子狀況,真不知道他能不能開演唱會。11.參加過的朋友們都在稱讚...我也應該去的。12.誰能比得上GD的天賦?真的是不簡單。 13.演員韓孝珠去看了GD的演唱會,還留下了尊敬的話。14.4小時的演唱會,GD想給更多的表現,真的太可愛了。15.我去了第一次演唱會,真的超好看的。 16.最終場真的太超值了,4小時耶!哪個出道19年的偶像能給你4小時的演出?17.我是第一次演唱會的參加者,看到最終場的後續,覺得沒去到真的很可惜,每天的服裝好像都不同,這就是為什麼整場演唱會才是王道,可是我的手太慢,搶不到票,嗚嗚。18.看了後續發現最終場真的不是開玩笑的。 19.大眾的反應也很好,這次演唱會的評價真不錯。20.先不說別的,能開4小時的演唱會...真的是最強者。21.去了中間場真的很幸福,好想再去一場啊...能不能搶到BIGBANG的票,真的好擔心。 22.不僅小朋友喜歡,還是一位能跨越時代的歌手23.我也是...第一次近距離看到他,臉好小好可愛,唱現場也超好聽的,嗚嗚嗚嗚。24.撒嬌超多,粉絲管理也超厲害,漂亮又帥又可愛,真的讓我被圈粉了! 25.我去了第一次演唱會,原本不是死忠粉,想說人生中要去看一次GD的演唱會,結果瞬間被圈粉了。他真的是細節大師,唱功什麼的都超強,尤其是現場的說唱完全沒有爭議。我本來以為他只是會作曲作詞又會打扮的時尚王,結果演唱會的故事性和意義讓我變得謙虛了哈哈,好想再去一場。26.真的最終場才是最讚的,超好看!27.真的是讓人著迷...好像心都被他偷走了。

泡菜鄉民a year ago
繁體中文
韓娛熱議-TWICE娜定雙璉(娜璉×定延)熱議討論

韓娛熱議-TWICE娜定雙璉(娜璉×定延)

下面是韓網的評論翻譯 1.拿著去現場的粉絲和拿著這個的歌手,真的太好笑了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈2.太好笑了哈哈哈哈 每次都乖乖接過去的成員們也好可愛3.傳統來了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 4.到這種程度,成員們是不是每次泰國演唱會都在期待這個?哈哈5.希望可以永遠持續下去哈哈哈哈哈哈6.兩個大美女這樣做真的太可愛了哈哈哈 7.粉絲的義氣真是大爆發,追星追了幾年,每次都做這個然後去看演唱會,真的太有毅力了8.永遠更新的娜定雙璉哈哈哈,本來就期待這次也會繼續,結果真的有,真開心哈哈,未來也期待新的娜定雙璉哈哈9.啊這個一直更新就很好笑了,還有每次都乖乖接過去也很好笑哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈,每次演唱會都能發現然後拿著拍照也不容易哈哈哈哈 10.就連定在娜璉和定延的位置拍照都好可愛哈哈11.之前出現過的臉再重現出來真的很有心12.老實說,當事人每次去泰國演唱會應該也會期待吧哈哈 13.如果娜定雙璉的橫幅不再出現,我自己可能都會覺得失落哈哈哈哈14.好可愛哦哈哈,這種和粉絲之間的傳統?還是說是回憶的延續,真的很棒哈哈哈哈15.真的超可愛哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 16.成員們的官方說法是“超級活動”哈哈哈哈哈哈 就算粉絲不能進到前排,成員們也會發現然後叫保安拿過來拍照17.已經變成傳統了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈18.TWICE真的太可愛了,即使我不是粉絲,每次看到還是覺得好喜歡 19.哇完全是歷史耶,超可愛哈哈哈哈20.啊好可愛哈哈哈,這種活動真是太棒了,請繼續做下去21.如果現在看不到的話,應該會覺得失落吧哈哈哈 22.這真是不能缺少的活動呢,好可愛哈哈哈23.這位粉絲為了不讓所有曼谷粉絲失望,應該每次都要坐在曼谷演唱會的第一排吧哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈24.是個人做的 從2017年開始只在泰國更新,所以成為了曼谷演唱會的傳統 每當曼谷演唱會要開的時候,很多粉絲都在期待橫幅更新,成員們也都收到這個橫幅,甚至說這是超級活動,真是有名哈哈哈哈 25.不是吧,我更驚訝的是這個橫幅的製作人一直能在顯眼的位置把這個交給他們,這不是個人做的吧?在粉絲之間是很有名的橫幅嗎?26.拿著娜定雙璉的娜定雙璉27.又好笑又可愛哈哈哈,每次TWICE要在泰國開演唱會時就期待這個哈哈

泡菜鄉民a year ago
繁體中文
韓娛熱議-很多人覺得有點不雅的RIIZE IG熱議討論

韓娛熱議-很多人覺得有點不雅的RIIZE IG

有人反映看到馬的特定身體部位 下面是韓網的評論翻譯 1.哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈什麼都看得到耶2.唉唷,這也太不雅了吧哈哈哈哈3.看起來像手煞車..; 4.我看這也太赤裸裸了吧,,5.哇,難怪動物節目要這麼認真做CG..6.原來國家地理的CG團隊這麼忙碌是有原因的ㅠㅠㅠ 7.這是官方帳號這樣直接放上去的嗎???8.喂!我真的不知道耶,現在看到才知道!!!!!9.還不晚啦,快修正一下ㅜ 10.不然就自然一點看吧ㅜ哈哈哈哈11.這就是為什麼紀錄片都要刪掉的原因哈哈哈哈12.如果可能的話,不是應該裁掉或貼個貼紙嗎,這是什麼啊 13.明明這麼明顯,為什麼不刪掉呢...?14.啊好不雅哈哈哈哈哈哈請刪掉重傳哈哈哈15.哇塞..無法忽視,太大了吧 16.動物也需要打馬賽克嗎?哈哈17.原來這就是紀錄片全部要修正的原因啊..視線無法移開,太誇張了18.上傳的人應該也不知道吧,我第一次看到的時候也完全沒想到那是那個 19.可是原本就長在那的,為什麼要刪掉呢,反正也不能塞回去20.哇,我本來不知道,看了文章再看照片就只看到那裡了;瘋了哈哈哈哈哈21.不過馬的毛光澤真不是開玩笑的,看那毛發閃亮亮的 22.那些員工都在幹嘛,明知道還敢上傳...?23.哇,結果一看到就被吸引住了,特別是第一張照片24.原本只看臉不知道,結果啊😱 25.啊真沒想到,如果我是負責人會刪掉再重傳嗎?26.為什麼不刪掉,連大象第五條腿在紀錄片裡都會刪掉哈哈27.我原本不知道,動物王國這種紀錄片是手動刪掉大物的 28.可是公馬就那樣,能怎樣呢哈哈哈,真的很礙眼的話,就拍模型或母馬,或者拍得不要出現29.不過這樣就算不雅嗎?反正是自然(?)的30.哇,沒人說的話我只會看馬的臉,眼睛都快壞掉了 ㄷㄷ 31.我看了那個Instagram也不知道..32.收藏什麼鬼哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈33.啊瘋了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈收藏是什麼意思 34.哇哈哈哈哈哈哈看文章之前完全沒發現35.啊瘋了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈36.哇,我看過這張照片,但只看臉所以不知道,瘋了 37.啊現在才知道哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈38.我找到了,說馬生殖器有1米39.是動物嘛...哈哈哈哈但說真的只看臉所以不知道 40.找了半天不知道哪裡不雅,結果往下拉看到啊哈哈哈哈哈哈41.啊天哪哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈不知道42.做為粉絲只看臉完全沒發現哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 43.哇...紀錄片裡負責刪掉馬或大象那個的人,應該整天只做這件事吧哈哈,後來應該變得心如止水44.聽說動物紀錄片要做CG所以花很多錢哈哈45.知道為什麼要刪了,真是崇高啊哈哈 46.收藏7個人是怎樣哈哈哈哈笑死我了47.哇完全不知道哈哈哈哈48.還以為衣服太暴露呢....快瘋了哈哈哈哈哈哈哈哈 49.哇,看這文章前看照片完全不知道哈哈哈哈哈哈瘋了這不雅

泡菜鄉民a year ago
繁體中文

Trending now

  1. 1

    Actor Lee Jung-hyun Announces Marriage on Live TV, Surprising Viewers

  2. 2

    CL Discusses Park Bom's Health, Explains Signing with THE BLACK LABEL

  3. 3

    NCT's Jeno Praised by Surgeon for "Irreproducible" Facial Structure

  4. 4

    Na Young-seok PD's Family Background Becomes Hot Topic, Netizens Surprised by Wife's Profession

  5. 5

    RESCENE Agency Director's Visuals Go Viral, Dubbed 'Sixth Member' — But Netizens Are Divided